Thus far everyone in the game is spectacularly bad at it (Faithfuls more so than Traitors), and as far as I can tell it’s because people in general no longer know how to think rationally.

Manos: the Hands of Fate (roughly translated to Hands: the Hands of Fate) should not feel personally attacked by me, since it's generally agreed to be up there in the top 10 of worst films of all time. It began life when an insurance-and-fertilizer salesman bet a screenwriter he could make a movie, easy, and so set out to do so.